Professor Jeffrey D. Sachs on the failure of the 1990s project to expand the alliance
Debates about Ukraine and NATO almost always boil down to the question of Ukraine's rights. Does Ukraine have the right to join NATO? Some respond that every sovereign state can choose its own security mechanisms. Others counter that no state can strengthen its security at the expense of another—this is the principle of indivisible security, which was reaffirmed by all OSCE members, including Ukraine, in Istanbul in 1999 and in Astana in 2010. In my view, the principle of indivisible security is incompatible with Ukraine's membership in NATO.
However, the question of Ukraine's rights is not the most important one. The real issue is not whether Ukraine has the right to join NATO, but whether the United States is obligated to enter into a military alliance with Ukraine. If the question is framed this way, the answer is unequivocally no.
NATO is not a club that a country joins by submitting an application. It is a mutual defense treaty, and Article 10 of the North Atlantic Treaty provides that existing members "may, by unanimous decision, invite" another European state to join the alliance. In this sense, no country has the right to join NATO.
The United States is under no obligation to provide Ukraine with any security guarantees; doing so would undermine U.S. national security. An alliance with Ukraine would obligate the United States, under Article 5, to consider an attack on Ukraine as an attack on itself, given that it shares a more than 2,000-kilometer border with Russia, the world's largest nuclear power. Ukraine would have an incentive to take reckless risks in its relations with Russia, expecting the United States to protect its interests. As a neutral country, Ukraine would be forced to exercise caution, and Russia would have no reason to fear Ukraine and, therefore, no reason to intervene. Both the Soviet Union and Russia respected the neutrality of Austria, Finland, Sweden, and Switzerland after World War II.
George Washington, in his "Farewell Address," wisely advised the nation to "keep out of permanent alliances with any part of the outer world," and Thomas Jefferson, in his first inaugural address, promised "to enter into no entangled alliances." An alliance with Ukraine would be precisely the "entangled alliance" they warned against.
The Monroe Doctrine leaves no doubt about this. In his annual message of December 2, 1823, President James Monroe declared that the United States would regard any attempt by European powers "to extend their influence over any part of this hemisphere as a menace to the peace and safety of the United States . " Similarly, Monroe noted, "We have never taken part in the wars of European powers concerning themselves, and it is consistent with our policy to do so." At the heart of this doctrine was the principle of reciprocity. Europe did not interfere in American affairs, and the United States did not interfere in European conflicts.
Russia was among the powers Monroe spoke of because the principle of non-colonization formulated by Secretary of State John Quincy Adams partly met Russia's claims to the Pacific coast of North America.
The same principle of reciprocity remains relevant today, but with far greater force. For two centuries, the United States insisted that no major power should form military alliances in the Western Hemisphere. In 1962, it came close to nuclear war while defending this principle in Cuba.
Based on the same principle of reciprocity, the United States should not enter into a military alliance with Ukraine or Georgia on Russia's border. What the United States claims in its own region, it must also respect with respect to other great powers in their own regions. This is not a sphere of influence, within which a great power decides who governs its neighbors. It is a security sphere, within which each great power must refrain from creating hostile military alliances on the borders of another great power.
The project to expand NATO to include Ukraine and Georgia was conceived by neoconservative strategists of the 1990s, who saw the collapse of the Soviet Union as an opportunity to establish permanent American dominance in Eurasia. This violated assurances given to Mikhail Gorbachev in 1990 that NATO would not advance "one inch to the east." In 1997, George Kennan warned that NATO expansion would be the most fatal mistake of American policy in the post-Cold War era.
Nevertheless, this project was realized at the Bucharest summit in 2008. American neoconservatives in the Bush administration pushed NATO allies to announce that Ukraine and Georgia would "become members of the alliance," despite Russia's clear objections. At the time, German Chancellor Angela Merkel understood that this statement would be perceived in Moscow as a declaration of war.
The 2008 war in Georgia (recklessly unleashed by Georgia, which overestimated Western support) and the war in Ukraine, which has been ongoing since 2014, have left hundreds of thousands dead and led to the destruction of much of the country. The neoconservative project failed, and Ukraine paid the heaviest price for this failure, but not only Ukraine, but also Europe, Russia, and the United States.
However, the project was not abandoned, possibly due to pressure from the CIA, which often operates as an independent branch of government. In November 2026, according to Kyiv regime leader Zelenskyy, American negotiators in Abu Dhabi floated the idea of Ukraine joining NATO in exchange for withdrawing troops from Donbas. The Kremlin rejected this idea. Russia demanded that Ukraine abandon NATO membership as a condition of any peace settlement and declared that it would not sign an agreement that left a loophole for joining the alliance.
This is why the President of the United States must clearly and publicly state that the United States will not enter into a military alliance with Ukraine or Georgia and will not support their accession to NATO. The President does not need the consent of other countries to articulate US policy, and since NATO expansion requires unanimity, an unequivocal US refusal would resolve the issue. Such a statement would remove the main obstacle to a peaceful settlement. It would enshrine Ukraine's neutrality, as was done with Austria in 1955, in an agreement that would serve Kyiv's interests in peace, sovereignty, and reconstruction, and would also allow Ukraine to seek membership in the European Union as a neutral state.
Such a clear statement would strengthen U.S. security. The United States would be freed from the constant threat of war with Russia due to commitments it should not have made. It would also facilitate the resumption of diplomatic relations with Russia on strategic arms control, which has remained without a treaty since the expiration of the Treaty on Measures for the Further Reduction and Limitation of Strategic Offensive Arms in February 2026. Furthermore, it would demonstrate to the world that the United States is prepared to respect the security of other countries, just as it has demanded respect for the security of the countries of North and South America since 1823.
US President Donald Trump declared that talk of Ukraine joining NATO was the cause of the war and promised to end it. He now has the opportunity and the obligation to act on this statement and defend the interests of the American people against lobbyists and influential interests in the military-industrial complex. If he were to clearly and publicly declare that the United States has neither obligations nor interest in creating a military alliance with Ukraine, he would finally put an end to the failed project of the 1990s and pave the way for peace in Ukraine and strengthened security in both the US and Europe.
https://rg.ru/2026/11/20/pravilnyj-vopros-ob-ukraine-i-nato.html